Skip to main content
(919) 234-7868
Carolina Insurance Group
INDEPENDENT INSURANCE AGENCY • GARNER, NC

Auto, Home & Business Insurance in Garner, NCHomegrown Strength. Southern Heart.

Independent insurance agents comparing coverage from multiple carriers for families and businesses in Garner, Fuquay-Varina, Holly Springs, Clayton, Raleigh and across North Carolina.

Phone hours Mon–Fri 9:00am–5:00pm · Garner office visits by appointment only

Independent Agency
We work for you, not one carrier
Wake & Johnston Counties
Garner • Fuquay-Varina • Holly Springs • Clayton
Multiple Carriers
Erie, Travelers, The Hartford, Nationwide & more
Real People
A local team that knows your policies

Independent Insurance Agency in Garner, NC

Carolina Insurance Group is a local, independent insurance agency at 500 Benson Rd, Suite 112 in Garner. Because we’re independent, we aren’t tied to one company. We compare coverage from several carriers, including Erie and Nationwide, and help you choose the policy that fits your car, home, family or business. Call (919) 234-7868 to talk with a licensed agent, or request a quote online.

Get a quote

  • Auto insurance: liability that meets North Carolina requirements, plus collision, comprehensive and uninsured motorist coverage.
  • Homeowners insurance: dwelling, personal property, liability and help choosing a wind and hail deductible that makes sense for central North Carolina.
  • Business insurance: general liability, business owner’s policies, commercial auto and workers’ compensation for contractors, restaurants, retail shops and offices.
  • Life insurance: term and whole life coverage to protect the people who depend on you.

Why Garner families and businesses work with us

  • One agent, many options. We shop your coverage with more than one carrier, so you can compare price and protection side by side.
  • A real local office. Call or email us Monday through Friday, 9:00 am to 5:00 pm. Our Garner office is by appointment only, so if you’d like to meet with an agent in person, call to schedule a time.
  • Help after the sale. We review policies when your life changes, answer billing and coverage questions, and help you through the claims process.
  • Bundle and save opportunities. Many clients combine auto, home and umbrella coverage. We’ll show you whether bundling actually lowers your total cost.

Areas we serve

From our office in Garner, we insure drivers, homeowners and business owners across Wake and Johnston counties, including Fuquay-Varina, Clayton, Holly Springs, Willow Spring, Raleigh, Cary, Apex, Angier and Benson. Most quotes can be handled by phone or email, so you don’t need to drive in.

Frequently asked questions

What does an independent insurance agency do?

An independent agency represents several insurance companies instead of one. We compare coverage and price from those carriers and recommend the option that fits you. We also stay your point of contact for changes and claims.

Can I get a quote without coming to the office?

Yes. Call (919) 234-7868 or use our online quote form. Have your current declarations page, driver’s license numbers and vehicle VINs (for auto) or your home’s age, square footage and roof year (for home) handy to speed things up.

Do you write business insurance outside Garner?

Yes. We help businesses throughout the Triangle and beyond with general liability, commercial property, commercial auto and workers’ compensation. See our business insurance page for the industries we work with.

Where is your office?

Carolina Insurance Group, 500 Benson Rd, Suite 112, Garner, NC 27529. Our office is open by appointment only. If you’d like to meet with someone in person, call (919) 234-7868 to schedule an appointment. Phone hours are Monday through Friday, 9:00 am to 5:00 pm. Get directions and office details.

Ready to compare coverage? Call (919) 234-7868 or request a free quote today.

WHAT WE OFFER

Insurance Built for Real Life in North Carolina

Whether you're protecting your family, home, business, or planning for retirement, we shop the market so you don't have to.

THE CAROLINA DIFFERENCE

Small agency.
Big advantage.

We're not tied to one insurance company. We work for you, shopping multiple carriers to find the right coverage at the right price.

  • Faster quotes — modern quoting tools plus personal service.
  • Better options — we compare policies from Erie, Travelers, The Hartford, Nationwide and others.
  • Local advocacy — when you have a claim, your Garner agency is on your side.
Independent vs. captive agents

Tech-Forward + Personal

Modern quoting tools help us get you accurate options quickly, without losing the personal touch of a local agency.

We Shop. You Compare.

Because we're independent, we compare carriers and coverage combinations to find a policy that fits your life and budget.

Local Roots

Ray Beaird grew up in Fuquay-Varina and founded the agency in 2011. We know the weather risks and what matters to families and business owners here.

Responsive & Reliable

Need a certificate, a policy change or claim help? You reach real people who know your name and your policies.

CARRIERS WE WORK WITH

Coverage from carriers we trust

As an independent agency, we are not owned by any insurance company. See all insurance companies

FROM OUR CLIENTS

What our neighbors are saying

“It was a good experience. It was not complicated, and everything was handled in a timely manner.”
— yolanda f
“Ray was very accommodating in servicing our needs on a pretty tight timeline. His communication was excellent, and he was very professional and a pleasure to work with.”
— Steve L
“We have been represented by Carolina Insurance Group for decades now. We have been very pleased with how responsive they are to our insurance needs.”
— Nan B

Areas we serve

Our only office is in Garner (by appointment). We work with clients by phone and email across North Carolina.

Ready to protect what matters most?

Get quotes from multiple carriers. No obligation.

Or call (919) 234-7868 · Office visits by appointment only