Skip to main content
(919) 234-7868
Carolina Insurance Group

That Guitar, Coin Collection, or Comic Book Stash Might Be Worth More Than Your Policy Covers

Published August 18, 2026

Most homeowners and renters policies include coverage for personal property — but that coverage is built for everyday belongings, not specialty items with values that go far beyond what a standard policy anticipates. If you own musical instruments, collectibles, or specialty items, there’s a good chance you’re underinsured without realizing it.

The Gap Standard Policies Don’t Fill

Homeowners and renters policies typically place sub-limits on certain categories of property — meaning even though your overall policy limit might be high, specific categories like jewelry, firearms, coin collections, or fine art are often capped at a few thousand dollars total, regardless of what your collection is actually worth.

Common items that fall into this gap include:

  • Musical instruments — a quality violin, guitar, or brass instrument can easily be worth several times what a standard policy would pay out
  • Gasoline and automotive memorabilia
  • Baseball cards and sports memorabilia
  • Artwork
  • Guns and knives
  • Costume and fine jewelry
  • Dolls and bears
  • Pottery and ceramics
  • Coins and stamps
  • Comic books and books

If any of these are damaged, lost, or stolen, a standard policy might only reimburse a small fraction of their real value — and in many cases, won’t cover certain causes of loss (like accidental breakage) at all.

The Fix: Scheduling Your Items

The solution is a scheduled personal property endorsement (sometimes called a personal articles floater). This allows you to insure specific high-value items at their appraised or documented value, with broader coverage than a standard policy provides — often including accidental damage, and coverage away from home.

Scheduling is usually inexpensive relative to the value it protects, and for most items, all that’s needed is a receipt, appraisal, or set of clear photos to establish value.

Why This Often Gets Overlooked

Many people don’t think of their hobby collection or family instrument as something that needs special insurance — it simply doesn’t come up until there’s a loss. A basement flood, a house fire, or even a break-in can wipe out a collection built over decades, and discovering the coverage gap after the fact is a hard place to be.

Take a Few Minutes to Check

If you have any specialty collection or high-value item at home, it’s worth a quick conversation to see whether it’s adequately protected. In most cases, scheduling these items is a simple, affordable add-on — not a complicated process.

Have a collection, instrument, or specialty item you want to make sure is covered? Reach out and we’ll walk through what it would take to properly protect it.

From our clients

What our clients say

“The company and staff is always very helpful”
— Charles G
“Ray Beaird is a good man. I have two cars insured with his office and would recommend Carolina Insurance Group to anyone. Truly a "customer comes first" operation.”
— Terence M
“I worked with Ray at Carolina Insurance Group and he made the insurance shopping experience easy, fast and pleasant. Very knowledgeable and helpful. I even recommended them to a friend already!”
— Michael L

Ready to compare your options?

Start a quote online or call (919) 234-7868. Our Garner office is by appointment only, so call ahead if you'd like to meet in person.